The brain and somatic integration: insights into the standard biological rationale for equating "brain death" with death.
نویسنده
چکیده
The mainstream rationale for equating "brain death" (BD) with death is that the brain confers integrative unity upon the body, transforming it from a mere collection of organs and tissues to an "organism as a whole." In support of this conclusion, the impressive list of the brain's myriad integrative functions is often cited. Upon closer examination, and after operational definition of terms, however, one discovers that most integrative functions of the brain are actually not somatically integrating, and, conversely, most integrative functions of the body are not brain-mediated. With respect to organism-level vitality, the brain's role is more modulatory than constitutive, enhancing the quality and survival potential of a presupposedly living organism. Integrative unity of a complex organism is an inherently nonlocalizable, holistic feature involving the mutual interaction among all the parts, not a top-down coordination imposed by one part upon a passive multiplicity of other parts. Loss of somatic integrative unity is not a physiologically tenable rationale for equating BD with death of the organism as a whole.
منابع مشابه
Integrated But Not Whole? Applying an Ontological Account of Human Organismal Unity to the Brain Death Debate1
As is clear in the 2008 report of the President’s Council on Bioethics, the brain death debate is plagued by ambiguity in the use of such terms as “integration” and “wholeness.” Addressing this problem, I offer a plausible ontological account of organismal unity by drawing on the work of Hoffman and Rosenkrantz. I then apply that account to the case of brain death and conclude that a brai-dead ...
متن کاملمطالعهی مرگ مغزی از منظر فقه و حقوق جزا
Brain death is a subject in our society which can be mistaken with coma or other types of life status similar to death. To assess the legal status of a brain dead patient, it is necessary to determine whether a person afflicted with brain death is dead or alive. Do they meet the criteria for biological death? Or in precise words, do Islamic laws for the dead apply to them? Several questions ari...
متن کاملA comparative study on effective factors on consent to organ donation among families of brain death victims in Isfahan, 2013
Objective: According to the previous studies, several social, cultural, and organizational factors are involved in the decision of families of brain death victims for organ donation. The present study was performed to determine the effective factors in the decision of organ donation among families of brain death victims. Methods: In this descriptive-com...
متن کاملبررسی تطبیقی مرگ مغزی در حقوق مصر و ایران
Failure to return all cerebellar and cerebellar cortex activities is called brain death. As the advancement of medical technology was first introduced in 1952 in the United States and a few years later in France, this concept was introduced. Today, most advanced countries in the world have accepted, through laws or judicial decisions, that death is due to the cessation of brain activity, and br...
متن کاملEvaluation of Cardiac Function in Patients with Brain Death using Advanced Hemodynamic Monitoring
Background: Studies on hemodynamic changes in brain death are in vitro and in animal studies. And very few studies have been done on the hemodynamic changes of brain death. The aim of this study was to use advanced hemodynamic monitoring with echocardiography for evaluation of donated heart and to evaluate the moment by moment brain death patients with advanced hemodynamic monitoring tools and ...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- The Journal of medicine and philosophy
دوره 26 5 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2001